Nobody Owns Money

Chapter 43. The Whalers

Part XII. What Remains11 min

43

The Whalers

An old photograph: a New Bedford wharf crowded with barrels, the masts of whaling ships behind them.archive
Merrill’s Wharf in New Bedford, 1870. The town got rich on whale oil, and the ships were fitted out by syndicates, the way startups are funded today. Source: Alpheus Hyatt Verrill, Public domain

In the mid-nineteenth century the richest city in America per capita was considered to be New Bedford, Massachusetts, and it grew rich on whales. From here whaling ships put out to sea and came back three, four, sometimes five years later, if they came back at all, with holds full of sperm oil, which lit homes and lubricated machines all over the world. Fitting out such a ship cost a fortune, and it was fitted out jointly. An agent-owner collected money from wealthy neighbours, hired a captain and a crew who were paid a share of the future catch, and together they all waited to see what the ocean would bring. Most often the ocean brought losses or a modest profit. Occasionally a ship came back with such a cargo that it paid for all its investors’ failed voyages for years ahead.

The Harvard economist Tom Nicholas, who wrote a history of American venture capital, begins it with the whalers. He calculated that roughly one and a half percent of whaling expeditions managed to double the money invested, while today almost three percent of venture funds show returns of more than one hundred percent a year. The distribution of profits is the same for both. Almost everyone loses, very few win so big that they cover everyone else, and for the sake of those few money is brought into the game again and again. Silicon Valley, which later raised Coinbase and bought up ICO tokens, remained a whaling cooperative in its structure. Crypto even inherited the word, and those whose wallets move a coin’s price are still called whales on the market.

Whaling ended when oil was found in Pennsylvania and homes began to be lit with kerosene. The oil for which men had sailed around Cape Horn for years became useless to anyone within a few decades, and New Bedford went from the richest city in the country to an ordinary one. Technologies that make big money sometimes disappear faster than their investors manage to notice.


A 17th-century painting: monkeys in fine clothes haggle over tulips, count money and feast.archive
Jan Brueghel the Younger, Satire on Tulip Mania, around 1640. Most of what everyone knows about the tulips came from satires like this, not from the archives. Source: Jan Brueghel the Younger, Public domain

The most famous story about a bubble happened in Holland in 1637, and most of what is told about it is made up. Everyone who has read even one popular book on finance knows that a bulb of a rare tulip then cost as much as a house on an Amsterdam canal, that thousands of people were ruined, and that a sailor, mistaking a bulb for an ordinary onion, ate it for breakfast and went to prison for it. The historian Anne Goldgar spent several years in Dutch archives and found almost none of this. Only thirty-seven people paid more than three hundred guilders, a carpenter’s annual earnings, for a bulb, among the tulip traders she found one who was ruined, and she did not find the sailor with the bulb at all. Prices really did soar and crash, only the game was played by a narrow circle of wealthy enthusiasts, and the whole country learned about it from satirical pamphlets with which preachers and moralists mocked greed.

After sign-in

The rest of the book is for signed-in readers

Sign in with INITE or create an account. It takes a minute, and the book opens right here.