A Lovely Computer

Interlude. Keys

Part IV. The Manufacturer Owns It5 min

Interlude. Keys

On the sixteenth of February 2016 a federal judge in Riverside, California, ordered the Apple company to write a program. The phone that made this necessary, an iPhone 5c, had been carried by a man who two and a half months earlier, together with his wife, had shot fourteen co-workers dead in San Bernardino and been killed by the police. The phone belonged to San Bernardino County, where the killer worked as a health inspector, and the county consented to its being opened. The lawful owner of the handset wanted to open it and could not. The phone was locked with a short numeric passcode. Trying every combination is not hard, but after a few mistakes the system stretches the pauses between attempts, and after the tenth it may erase everything. The FBI wanted from Apple a special version of the system with no pauses and no erasing, signed with Apple’s key, because without that signature the phone would not have accepted it.

All the technology described in the preceding chapters worked, in this case, against the state. The boot chain that keeps foreign code off the phone kept the FBI’s code off it too. The signature without which I could not run my own program on my own handset turned out to be the only thing standing between the investigators and the contents of the phone, and the only key to it was Apple’s.

Tim Cook published an open letter to customers the same day. He wrote that the company was being required to make a master key, that a master key, once made, would open any such phone, and that it was too dangerous to create. The dispute was about to be heard in court, both sides were gathering allies, and a day before the hearing the Department of Justice asked for it to be postponed. On the twenty-eighth of March it said that the data had been extracted from the phone and Apple’s help was no longer required. Some unnamed third party had sold the FBI a method. A ruling that would have answered whether the state can compel a firm to write programs against its own customers was never handed down.

Free, one step away

The rest of the book is free

Leave your email and I will send a link to confirm it. Once you click it, every chapter opens here, on this device, for a year. When a new book comes out I will write to this address; reply “stop” to any email and I will not write again.

Have an INITE account? Sign in and the book opens without an email.

I do not charge for the book. If you would like to support it, you can donate from any chapter.

How your email is stored