A Lovely Computer

Chapter 17. The Court

Part IV. The Manufacturer Owns It5 min

17

The Court

On the thirteenth of August 2020 the company Epic Games switched on its own payment for purchases in the game Fortnite, at a discount and bypassing Apple. Apple removed the game from the store the same day. Epic the same day filed a complaint of sixty-odd pages, which, to judge by its length, had not been written that morning, and released a video that restaged Apple’s advertising film about 1984, only with an apple in the part of the grey dictator on the screen. Two weeks later, on the twenty-eighth of August, Apple closed Epic’s developer account entirely. A company that had once promised that 1984 would not be like “1984” got its advertisement back in the post.

The trial was held in Oakland before Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers. The witnesses were the heads of both companies, and the subject of the proceedings was everything this book has spoken of as engineering. The signature without which a program will not launch on the phone was called, in the courtroom, a restriction on distribution, the thirty per cent was called a supracompetitive commission, and the review rules were entered into the record as evidence.

On the tenth of September 2021 the judge gave her ruling. On nine counts out of ten she sided with Apple. She did not find the company a monopolist, did not oblige it to open the phone to other stores, and confirmed that Epic had breached the agreement and that the game had been removed lawfully. The tenth count concerned California’s unfair competition law. Apple forbade developers to tell the buyer inside a program that the same thing was sold more cheaply on a website, and that ban the court ordered lifted.

Free, one step away

The rest of the book is free

Leave your email and I will send a link to confirm it. Once you click it, every chapter opens here, on this device, for a year. When a new book comes out I will write to this address; reply “stop” to any email and I will not write again.

Have an INITE account? Sign in and the book opens without an email.

I do not charge for the book. If you would like to support it, you can donate from any chapter.

How your email is stored