01
Slots
I was five, and it was the second time in my life I had seen a computer. This was in Stavropol, in 1989 or 1990, still under the Soviet Union, in a kindergarten called the Golden Key. I did not go there myself; I went to the Firebird. But my father worked at the Golden Key as the electrician, and that was where they had set up an experimental computer class.
The computers in the class were called Agat, and what the children got on them was games and a drawing program. I remember the red colour monitors, converted from portable television sets, as if I had seen them yesterday, and from the reference books I now also know the make of the television, a Yunost. Everything else I see through fog. The children’s machines, I think, had no disk drives of their own. The only drive stood next to the teacher’s black-and-white monitor, and she decided which game would be on everyone’s screen today. Classes like this were being set up in kindergartens at the end of the eighties by the Research Institute of Preschool Education of the Academy of Pedagogical Sciences, which from 1986 had been testing whether computer games were any good for teaching preschoolers, and the official name for the thing was a computer play complex. Schools got their Agats with a disk drive in every machine and no wires between them; our kindergarten got a rare set with network cards, where one master machine handed out programs to all the others over a cable. One day, while the teacher was out of the room, I sat down at that master machine and started a different game, on my own, by typing a command on the keyboard. How a five-year-old who was seeing a computer for the second time worked out what to type and where, I cannot explain, because memory kept the result and threw away the method. It also kept the teacher, who came back, looked at the screen, understood what had happened, and could not find a single word.
The computer did not ask who I was. It did not care whether I was five or forty, or whether I was the kindergarten’s teacher or the electrician’s son, and it carried out the command of the person sitting at the keyboard, because it had no other way of telling who its owner was. The phone in my pocket now, before it runs a program, checks the signature of whoever made it, consults a list of what that program is allowed to do, and from time to time asks to see my face. I feel like the owner of that phone a good deal less than I felt like the owner of somebody else’s Agat in somebody else’s kindergarten.
The Agat was a Soviet version of the American Apple II, and such a free one that the most common model, the Agat-7, would not run software written for the original without an extra card. In November 1984 the American magazine Byte ran an article about it called “Agat: A Soviet Apple II Computer”, with a subtitle about a bad copy. It was written by Leo Bores, an eye surgeon from Arizona who had travelled to Moscow to see Svyatoslav Fyodorov, met the machine there, and christened it, in Russian, Yabloko. Later the Agat’s devotees began to argue that there were no production machines yet at the time of Bores’s trips and that he had reviewed a debugging prototype, which would mean that what the American press called a bad copy was a rough draft.
The Apple II was easier to copy than any other computer, for a reason Cupertino had created itself. In January 1978 Apple published a reference manual for it, known as the Red Book, and printed in it the machine’s circuit diagrams and a commented listing of its system program. The buyer got a computer together with the drawing from which you could build a second one. Whether the Red Book lay on the desks of the Agat’s designers I do not know, but Bulgaria built the Pravetz on the pattern of the Apple II, the Soviet Union built the Agat, and none of them had to guess how the original worked.
Across the ocean a company called Franklin, of New Jersey, was doing the same thing, and it had less luck than the Agat. Its Ace computer was an Apple II in almost every respect, including the programs in the read-only memory chips, which Franklin had copied from the original byte for byte and did not deny copying. In court it argued that a program burned into a chip is a machine part, like a gear, and that gears cannot be copyrighted, and the trial court agreed. On the thirtieth of August 1983 the court of appeals decided the opposite. A program is protected as a literary work in any form, whether as source text or as ones and zeros inside a chip, and that goes for an operating system too. Apple printed the schematic of its machine in the manual and let anyone copy the hardware. What it chose to defend in court was the code, and since that ruling a program inside somebody else’s computer has always had an owner, and the owner is its author.
The lid of an Apple II is not fastened by anything and comes off in your hands, and under it, in a row, are eight slots for expansion cards, over which Apple’s two founders quarrelled. Steve Jobs wanted to leave two, one for a printer and one for a modem; he thought the buyer would never need more, and he called slots inelegant. Steve Wozniak, who had designed the computer, demanded eight, because from his job at Hewlett-Packard he knew that people find a use for any slot that is free. By his own account he told Jobs that if he wanted two slots he could go and find himself another computer, and many years later he admitted that he had probably been bluffing. Eight slots stayed.
Into them, later, went memory cards, disk controllers and everything else people managed to think up in the sixteen years the machine stayed in production. The Apple II was shown to the public in April 1977 and manufactured until 1993, and it sold, by various estimates, between five and six and a half million units, since Apple never gave exact figures. The Agat, if the historians of Soviet hardware are to be believed, was taken out of production in that same 1993.
Jobs lost the argument about slots, and he made the next machines his own way. The first was the Apple III, announced in May 1980. Jobs took charge of how it looked and banned both a fan and ventilation slots from the case, because a fan is noisy and slots are ugly. The heat was supposed to leave through a cast aluminium base. The base could not cope, the board inside heated up and warped, and the chips slowly crept out of their sockets, after which the computer froze or filled the screen with garbage. Owners, the story goes, were advised to lift the machine a few centimetres off the desk and drop it, so that the jolt would seat the chips again. Apple replaced thousands of computers free of charge. It may be the only case in the history of technology in which the manufacturer’s instructions consisted of dropping the product.
The Macintosh, which came out in January 1984, had no slots at all. The case was closed with Torx screws, which almost nobody had heard of at the time, and those screws were sunk so deep that you needed a screwdriver some twenty-five centimetres long, and after that a special tool to pry the two halves of the case apart. On the inside of the back panel are the moulded signatures of the people who made the computer, Jobs’s own among them, so that the authors signed their work in a place the owner was not supposed to look.
Apple went on selling the Apple II and the Macintosh side by side for another nine years, and all that time one catalogue held a computer that came with its own schematic and a computer with autographs under lock and key.